Mental Health 12 min read

Understanding Compulsive Overeating: When Food Becomes a Coping Mechanism

Dr. Mariia Tanasyshyn, ND, MD (UA)
Mental Health, Emotional Eating
Smiling woman enjoying yogurt from a plastic cup, savoring each creamy spoonful while embracing a healthy lifestyle indoors

Do you find yourself eating when you're not hungry? Reaching for food when you're stressed, sad, or bored? If so, you may be experiencing compulsive overeating—a pattern of using food to cope with emotions rather than to satisfy physical hunger.

Compulsive overeating is different from Binge Eating Disorder (BED), though they share some similarities. While both involve eating beyond physical need, compulsive overeating is characterized by chronic, habitual overeating—often grazing throughout the day—rather than discrete binge episodes. Let's explore what compulsive overeating really is, what drives it, and most importantly, how to break the cycle.

What Is Compulsive Overeating?

Compulsive overeating refers to the chronic, habitual consumption of food beyond what the body needs for energy and nourishment. Unlike Binge Eating Disorder—which involves discrete episodes of consuming large amounts of food in a short time with a sense of loss of control—compulsive overeating is typically more gradual and ongoing.

Common Characteristics

  • Eating when not physically hungry
  • Eating in response to emotions (stress, sadness, boredom, loneliness, anxiety)
  • Continuing to eat even when comfortably full
  • Grazing or snacking throughout the day without awareness
  • Feeling guilty or ashamed about eating behaviors
  • Eating quickly or mindlessly (while watching TV, working, etc.)
  • Using food as a primary coping mechanism for difficult feelings
  • Difficulty stopping once you start eating certain foods
  • Hiding food or eating in secret

How Compulsive Overeating Differs from Binge Eating Disorder

BED

Discrete episodes of eating unusually large amounts in a short period (e.g., 2 hours) with a clear sense of loss of control

COE

More chronic, ongoing pattern of overeating throughout the day—grazing, frequent snacking, eating larger portions at meals

BED

Typically involves consuming very large quantities during binge episodes

COE

May involve moderate overeating repeatedly rather than extreme binges

BED

Formal diagnostic criteria (DSM-5)

COE

Not an official DSM-5 diagnosis; considered a disordered eating pattern

Note: Some people with compulsive overeating may also meet criteria for BED. These conditions can overlap or exist on a spectrum. Professional assessment is important.

How Common Is It?

Because compulsive overeating isn't a formal diagnosis, exact prevalence rates are hard to determine. However, research suggests that disordered eating behaviors are extremely common—affecting as many as 20-30% of adults at some point in their lives. Emotional eating and chronic overeating are among the most common patterns.

Compulsive overeating affects people of all genders, ages, body sizes, and backgrounds. It's not about a lack of willpower or discipline—it's a complex behavior pattern rooted in emotional regulation, learned habits, and often, underlying physiological factors.

Why Does Compulsive Overeating Happen?

Compulsive overeating develops through a combination of psychological, biological, and environmental factors. Understanding these root causes is essential for healing.

1. Emotional & Psychological Factors

  • Emotional regulation difficulties: Using food to soothe, numb, or distract from uncomfortable emotions like stress, anxiety, sadness, anger, or loneliness.
  • Learned behavior: Many people grow up in environments where food is used as comfort, reward, or celebration—creating strong emotional associations with eating.
  • Stress and overwhelm: Chronic stress elevates cortisol, which increases appetite and cravings for high-calorie comfort foods.
  • Depression and anxiety: Mental health struggles often coexist with disordered eating patterns.
  • Trauma history: Past trauma—particularly in childhood—can lead to using food as a source of safety and control.
  • Low self-esteem and poor body image: Negative self-perception can create a cycle of emotional eating and guilt.

2. Biological & Physiological Factors

  • Blood sugar dysregulation: Unstable blood sugar leads to intense cravings and overeating cycles. Insulin resistance can worsen this pattern.
  • Neurotransmitter imbalances: Low serotonin, dopamine, or GABA can drive cravings for foods that temporarily boost these brain chemicals.
  • Hormonal factors: Imbalances in leptin (satiety hormone), ghrelin (hunger hormone), cortisol, thyroid hormones, or sex hormones can affect appetite and eating behavior.
  • Gut microbiome imbalances: Emerging research shows the gut microbiome influences cravings, mood, and eating behavior through the gut-brain axis.
  • Nutrient deficiencies: Deficiencies in magnesium, zinc, B vitamins, omega-3s, or other nutrients can increase cravings and affect mood.
  • Sleep deprivation: Poor sleep disrupts hunger hormones and increases appetite, particularly for high-calorie foods.

3. Diet Culture & Environmental Factors

  • Chronic dieting and restriction: This is the #1 driver of compulsive overeating. Restriction creates biological and psychological deprivation, leading to overeating when food becomes available.
  • "Good" vs. "bad" food mentality: Labeling foods as off-limits creates forbidden fruit appeal and increases obsessive thinking about those foods.
  • Hyperpalatable processed foods: Modern food engineering creates foods designed to override satiety signals—high in sugar, fat, and salt combinations not found in nature.
  • Food as entertainment and distraction: In our culture, food is everywhere—used for socializing, entertainment, stress relief, and celebration beyond nutritional need.
  • Mindless eating environments: Eating while watching screens, working, or distracted prevents awareness of hunger/fullness cues.

Key Understanding

Compulsive overeating is not a character flaw or lack of willpower. It's a learned coping mechanism—often rooted in emotional needs, biological imbalances, and diet culture damage. The solution isn't more restriction or self-control. It's addressing the underlying causes with compassion and support.

Health Impact of Chronic Overeating

While compulsive overeating may seem less severe than other eating disorders, chronic overeating has real consequences for both physical and mental health.

Physical Health Effects

  • Weight gain and difficulty maintaining a healthy weight
  • Increased risk of type 2 diabetes and insulin resistance
  • High blood pressure and cardiovascular disease risk
  • High cholesterol and triglycerides
  • Digestive issues (bloating, acid reflux, constipation)
  • Chronic inflammation throughout the body
  • Fatty liver disease (non-alcoholic)
  • Joint pain and mobility issues
  • Sleep disturbances and fatigue
  • Hormonal imbalances

Mental & Emotional Impact

  • Guilt and shame: Constant negative self-judgment around eating behavior
  • Loss of body trust: Disconnection from hunger and fullness cues
  • Food preoccupation: Constantly thinking about food, what to eat, what not to eat
  • Reduced self-esteem: Feeling like a failure for not being able to "control" eating
  • Anxiety and depression: Worsening of mental health symptoms
  • Social withdrawal: Avoiding social eating situations or activities
  • The diet-binge cycle: Repeated attempts to restrict followed by overeating

The Compulsive Overeating Cycle

1

Trigger: Stress, emotion, or restriction

2

Overeating: Using food to cope or feel better

3

Guilt/Shame: "I have no self-control"

4

Restriction: "I'll start a diet tomorrow"

Cycle repeats, getting stronger each time

Breaking the Cycle

The good news? This cycle can be broken. With the right support, you can heal your relationship with food, develop healthier coping strategies, and find freedom from compulsive overeating. It starts with understanding that restriction is not the answer—compassion and addressing root causes is.

How to Heal from Compulsive Overeating

Healing from compulsive overeating requires a compassionate, multifaceted approach that addresses the psychological, behavioral, and physiological aspects of the pattern.

1. Psychological Support & Therapy

Working with a therapist who specializes in eating issues is invaluable for addressing the emotional roots of compulsive overeating.

Effective therapeutic approaches:

  • Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT): Identifies and changes thought patterns and behaviors around food
  • Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT): Teaches emotional regulation and distress tolerance skills
  • Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT): Develops psychological flexibility and values-based living
  • Psychodynamic therapy: Explores underlying emotional patterns and past experiences
  • Trauma-focused therapy (EMDR, Somatic): If trauma is a contributing factor

2. Intuitive Eating & Anti-Diet Nutrition

Working with a non-diet dietitian who practices Intuitive Eating or Health at Every Size (HAES) can help you rebuild trust with your body and food.

Core principles of Intuitive Eating:

  • Reject the diet mentality
  • Honor your hunger
  • Make peace with food (no forbidden foods)
  • Challenge the "food police" thoughts
  • Discover the satisfaction factor
  • Feel your fullness
  • Cope with emotions without using food
  • Respect your body
  • Exercise for joy, not punishment
  • Honor your health with gentle nutrition

3. Mindfulness & Present-Moment Awareness

Mindfulness practices help you become aware of eating patterns, emotional triggers, and physical sensations without judgment.

Mindful eating practices:

  • Eat without distractions (no screens, work, or multitasking)
  • Notice the colors, textures, smells, and flavors of food
  • Chew slowly and put utensils down between bites
  • Check in with hunger and fullness levels throughout the meal
  • Pause halfway through to assess if you're still hungry
  • Practice self-compassion if you overeat—no judgment

4. Alternative Coping Strategies

Learning to cope with emotions without food is essential. Build a toolbox of non-food coping strategies.

For Stress/Anxiety:

  • Deep breathing exercises
  • Progressive muscle relaxation
  • Walking or gentle movement
  • Journaling
  • Talking to a friend

For Sadness/Loneliness:

  • Reaching out to loved ones
  • Engaging in creative expression
  • Watching a comforting movie
  • Taking a warm bath
  • Cuddling with a pet

For Boredom:

  • Starting a hobby or project
  • Reading a book
  • Listening to music or podcasts
  • Going outside for fresh air
  • Organizing a space

For Celebration/Joy:

  • Sharing good news with others
  • Dancing or moving your body
  • Buying yourself flowers
  • Planning a fun experience
  • Doing something meaningful

5. Naturopathic & Root Cause Approach

A naturopathic doctor can investigate and address the biological imbalances that may be driving cravings and overeating patterns.

Naturopathic interventions:

  • Blood sugar balance: Using diet, supplements, and herbs to stabilize glucose levels
  • Neurotransmitter support: Amino acids (5-HTP, L-tyrosine, L-theanine) and cofactors to support serotonin, dopamine, GABA
  • Gut healing: Addressing dysbiosis, inflammation, and the gut-brain axis
  • Hormone optimization: Balancing cortisol, thyroid, sex hormones, insulin
  • Nutrient repletion: Correcting deficiencies that affect mood and cravings
  • Stress management: Adaptogenic herbs (ashwagandha, rhodiola), nervous system support
  • Sleep optimization: Addressing sleep issues that worsen eating patterns

Practical Steps You Can Take Today

If you're ready to start healing from compulsive overeating, here are concrete steps you can begin implementing right away:

1

Stop Dieting—For Good

This is the most important step. Restriction fuels compulsive overeating. Give yourself unconditional permission to eat all foods. Trust that once you stop restricting, your body will begin to regulate naturally.

2

Practice "Pause and Name"

Before eating, pause for 10 seconds. Ask yourself: "Am I physically hungry, or am I eating for another reason?" Name the emotion or trigger without judgment. This builds awareness—the foundation of change.

3

Eat Regularly Throughout the Day

Don't skip meals or go too long without eating. Aim for 3 meals and 2-3 snacks. Consistent eating prevents extreme hunger, which often triggers overeating.

4

Build an Emotion Toolkit

Create a list of 10-15 things you can do instead of eating when you're not physically hungry. Keep it visible (on your phone, fridge, journal). When the urge hits, try one strategy for 10 minutes.

Remember: It's okay if you still eat. The goal is building awareness and options, not perfection.

5

Challenge "Food Rules"

Notice the rules you have about food ("I shouldn't eat after 7pm," "carbs are bad," "I can only have dessert on weekends"). These rules create restriction and rebellion. Start gently challenging one rule at a time.

6

Practice Radical Self-Compassion

When you overeat, respond to yourself with kindness—as you would to a friend. Replace "I'm so weak" with "I'm struggling right now, and that's okay. What do I need?" Self-compassion breaks the shame cycle.

7

Seek Professional Support

You don't have to do this alone. Working with a therapist, naturopathic doctor, or anti-diet dietitian can accelerate healing and provide personalized support for your unique situation.

What NOT to Do

  • Don't try another diet or "clean eating" plan. These are forms of restriction that will perpetuate the cycle.
  • Don't keep a food diary focused on calories or "good/bad" foods. This reinforces restriction mentality.
  • Don't weigh yourself daily or obsess over weight. Healing happens when you shift focus away from weight.
  • Don't expect perfection or overnight change. Healing is a non-linear process that takes time and patience.

Freedom Is Possible

Thousands of people have healed from compulsive overeating and developed peaceful, joyful relationships with food. You don't have to spend the rest of your life fighting with food or your body. With compassionate support and the right approach, you can find lasting freedom.

Final Thoughts

Compulsive overeating is a common, understandable response to emotional pain, chronic dieting, and a food environment designed to override our natural hunger cues. It's not about willpower—it's about unmet needs, unprocessed emotions, and often, underlying physiological imbalances.

The path to healing isn't through more restriction, discipline, or self-punishment. It's through self-compassion, addressing root causes, building emotional coping skills, and relearning to trust your body's innate wisdom. You deserve to have a peaceful relationship with food—one where eating is nourishing, enjoyable, and free from guilt or obsession.

A Naturopathic Perspective on Compulsive Overeating

In naturopathic medicine, we view compulsive overeating through a holistic lens that honors both the mind and body. While emotional support is essential, we also investigate the biological factors that may be driving the behavior—blood sugar imbalances, hormone dysregulation, neurotransmitter deficiencies, gut health issues, and nutrient status.

Our approach is compassionate and root-cause focused. We don't prescribe diets or focus on weight loss. Instead, we work to balance your body's systems so that cravings naturally diminish, mood stabilizes, and your relationship with food can heal. Every person's journey is unique, and we're here to support you with evidence-based natural medicine, lifestyle counseling, and unwavering compassion.

Selected References

  1. Tribole E, Resch E. Intuitive Eating: A Revolutionary Anti-Diet Approach. 4th ed. New York: St. Martin's Essentials; 2020.
  2. Herman CP, Mack D. Restrained and unrestrained eating. J Pers. 1975;43(4):647-660.
  3. Polivy J, Herman CP. Dieting and binging: A causal analysis. Am Psychol. 1985;40(2):193-201.
  4. Kristeller JL, Wolever RQ. Mindfulness-based eating awareness training for treating binge eating disorder: the conceptual foundation. Eat Disord. 2011;19(1):49-61.
  5. Tylka TL, et al. The weight-inclusive versus weight-normative approach to health: evaluating the evidence for prioritizing well-being over weight loss. J Obes. 2014;2014:983495.
  6. Bacon L, Aphramor L. Weight science: evaluating the evidence for a paradigm shift. Nutr J. 2011;10:9.
  7. van Strien T, et al. Emotional eating as a mediator between depression and weight gain. Appetite. 2016;100:216-224.
  8. Sinha R, Jastreboff AM. Stress as a common risk factor for obesity and addiction. Biol Psychiatry. 2013;73(9):827-835.

Ready to Break Free from Compulsive Overeating?

Work with Dr. Mariia Tanasyshyn to develop a compassionate, root-cause approach to healing your relationship with food. Integrative care available across Ontario.

Book Your First Visit Free 15-Min Call

Recommended Resources

  • Books: "Intuitive Eating" by Evelyn Tribole & Elyse Resch, "The F*ck It Diet" by Caroline Dooner
  • Podcasts: Food Psych, Don't Salt My Game, Love Food Podcast
  • Support: National Eating Disorder Information Centre (NEDIC) – 1-866-633-4220

Share This Article

Back to All Articles